Boston Jimmie
We at Stogie Press believe in honest cigar reviews.
We don’t put numbers in our cigar reviews. We do cigar reviews like this so as to benefit the consumer and supplier alike. Every cigar deserves an honest cigar review. Feel free to comment on any of our honest cigar reviews or if you like, submit us one of your honest cigar reviews and we will add to the list. We are unbiased in our cigar reviews and hope you are too.
We have rolled out our new rating system in time for the 86th annual IPCPR and all reviews here forward will be subjected to the new system. You can read about it in the three articles we published.
Click a brand on our “Big List” to be taken to our honest cigar reviews and another brand related information for that manufacturer. If you are a cigar manufacturer and would like us to do cigar reviews on your brands and blends, feel free to contact us.
Brand Owners – If you would like a high definition Stogie Press ratings badge that you can use in your print advertising, for a cigar we reviewed for you, just contact us.
Featured Cigar of the Week
Family by Loyalty FREKI Box Pressed Toro Rated 98 – 2024 Top Cigar of the Year

The Family By Loyalty Cigars – Freki Box Press Toro journey begins with subtle notes of white pepper and caramel, laying a flavorful foundation. In the background, gentle floral hints gradually unfold, adding a delicate complexity. A light grey ash forms atop a thin char line, marking the cigar’s steady progress. Sweet vanilla cream enters the mix, providing a harmonious balance to the developing flavors. The draw remains smooth, offering a full volume of smoke with each puff. Rich chocolate notes make an appearance deep in the first third, adding depth to the profile. As the cigar progresses into the second third, a tantalizing hint of mint brightens the overall experience. Natural sweetness emerges at the core, complemented by the addition of mouthwatering citrus rind, which enhances the already pleasant profile. Midway, the initial chocolate transforms into a darker, more robust chocolate. A sweet, lingering nutty note rests gently on the palate, while a subtle spice graces the taste buds deep into the second third. Moving through the final, an earthy note evolves, bringing the experience to an extremely satisfying finish. This is by far an amazing cigar and should be in everyone’s rotation. It should be approachable to all cigar enthusiasts with its complex yet balanced medium strength profile. Most certainly a box buy, if you are looking for a flavorful and satisfying experience. The extreme ash is just an added bonus overall. I rate this a rock solid 98.
Hello, how would I submit a cigar for review?
Message on Facebook under Boston Jimmie